Skip to the main content

#ANALYSE · Live feed · Ouest

MonCash, NatCash: Haiti's police say they flagged 18,000 suspicious transfers. What does the law say?

Illustration photo : Kendra Helmer / USAID · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons
0

By Carmelle Valmont

3 min read

The Haitian National Police (PNH) say they have flagged more than 18,000 suspicious transactions on NatCash and MonCash in 72 hours. In a statement released on Tuesday, November 17, by its communications department, the police described transfers of 5,000 to 15,000 gourdes and said they are investigating possible links to gangs. That raises a question: how can the police see these transactions, and what does the law say?

What the police say

According to the statement, the PNH's intelligence services, working with the Central Directorate of the Judicial Police (DCPJ), identified the transfers. The police say the repeated amounts and the frequency of the operations point to money laundering, concealment of funds and the financing of criminal networks. They also raise the possibility that the transfers were meant to coordinate actions against the security forces, without presenting it as an established finding.

The PNH named no one and announced no arrests. The statement does not say how the police obtained the data or on what legal basis, and it does not mention Digicel, Natcom or the Bank of the Republic of Haiti (BRH).

What the Constitution says

Article 49 of the 1987 Constitution protects the freedom and privacy of correspondence and of all other forms of communication. It allows them to be limited only by a reasoned decision of the judicial authority, within the guarantees set by law. In other words, in principle it is a judge, not the police alone, who can open access to private communications.

What the anti-money-laundering law says

The November 2013 law on money laundering and terrorist financing, amended in 2016, provides two main routes.

The first goes through the Central Financial Intelligence Unit (UCREF). Financial institutions, including money transfer houses, must report suspicious operations to it. UCREF can request further information, block an operation for 48 hours and then freeze it for 10 days, and send a report to the government prosecutor when there are serious indications.

The second goes through the investigating judge. By a reasoned decision and for a limited time, the judge can order the monitoring of bank accounts and similar accounts, as well as access to computer systems and servers. The judge can also have funds linked to the offense frozen. Employees who report a suspicious operation in good faith cannot be prosecuted for breaching professional secrecy.

Electronic payment services such as MonCash and NatCash are also regulated by the BRH, whose Circular No. 121 sets the rules on licensing, risk management, transaction security and supervision for electronic payment providers.

What it means for users

A transfer of 5,000 to 15,000 gourdes is an everyday operation for millions of Haitians. A transaction being flagged does not make the person who sent it a suspect. So far the PNH has named no one, and anyone targeted by an investigation is presumed innocent. The question the statement leaves open is the legal route: reports from the operators to UCREF, a judge's order, or something else. A clarification from the police or the prosecutor's office would answer it.

More on this story

← Back to the live feed

Comments 0

An editor reads every comment before it appears. NAGO does not publish a comment it has not read.

  • Loading comments…